BETHLEHEM, Pa. — Pennsylvania stores will be allowed to sell only 159 nicotine vape products from six manufacturers when the state begins enforcing its ban on unlisted vapes Oct. 19, according to the attorney general’s list Saturday.
At Jack’s Vape & Tobacco on Linden Street in Bethlehem on Saturday, glass cases were stocked with Geek Bar, Oxbar, and other disposable brands not on that list.
The officials behind the ban say most vapes on store shelves were never legal to sell. Federal law requires Food and Drug Administration authorization, and as of April, the FDA had authorized 41 products, none in flavors other than tobacco or menthol. That makes the vast majority of vapes being sold illegal, Attorney General Dave Sunday’s office said then.
But the FDA does not publish which products it has approved, denied or left pending, so states could not tell which were legal, the law’s sponsor, state Rep. Jeanne McNeill, a Lehigh County Democrat, told colleagues in a 2025 memo. Act 57 of 2025 gives Pennsylvania its own list, a directory kept by Sunday’s office, and lets the state seize unlisted products from sellers.
“This law is about keeping harmful products out of the hands of both children and adults who may not realize what they are consuming,” Sunday said Thursday.
Neither Sunday’s statements on the law nor McNeill’s memo cite a specific death or injury. Both cite young people. About 1.44 million U.S. middle and high school students vaped in 2025, two-thirds of them using disposables and 89% using flavors, according to the FDA’s youth survey. Four of the five brands they named most, Geek Bar, Elf Bar, Lost Mary and Raz, are not on Pennsylvania’s list.
Customers face no penalty for buying or keeping unlisted vapes.
Who gains, who loses
Three companies hold 108 of the listings, or 68%: R.J. Reynolds Vapor Co. with 52 Vuse products, Juul Labs with 40 and NJOY, owned by Marlboro maker Altria, with 16.
Retailers suing to block the law tie it to those companies. Their federal complaint, filed May 20, says the nation’s largest tobacco companies tried and failed to get federal regulators to exclude competing vapes, and that state bills like Pennsylvania’s followed.
Tobacco Hut, the retail chain among the plaintiffs, says it has 33 Pennsylvania stores and more than 170 employees, draws at least 60% of net profit from vapes the law bars and would have to close. The public docket copy, last updated June 13, shows no ruling.
About 11,090 Pennsylvania businesses hold the state license that covers vape sales, Sunday’s office said in April.
Pennsylvania's approved vape list, by manufacturer
Three companies hold 108 of the 159 listings as of Oct. 10.
The list could grow
The office says it is reviewing filings from 22 more manufacturers. A sheet dated Tuesday names 12 of them, seeking approval for 442 products including blu, Logic and Juice Head.
What it costs a store
A first offense is $500 per unlisted product, and the law counts each device, so 100 on a shelf works out to $50,000. Repeat violations within 12 months can result in up to $1,500 per product per day and the loss of the store’s license.
A manager at Jack’s, who declined to give his name or speak for the business, said the store expects to clear unlisted products from its shelves when the deadline comes. He said he did not know what would happen to them and that vendors might give credit.
The law gave stores 120 days to sell or remove unlisted stock. It requires manufacturers to take back and refund only products that are later removed from the list.
How Lehigh Valley lawmakers voted
The House passed the final version 147-56 on Dec. 16, 2025. Ten of the 11 members from districts covering parts of Lehigh or Northampton counties voted yes: Democrats McNeill, Robert Freeman, Steve Samuelson, Michael Schlossberg, Peter Schweyer and Joshua Siegel, whose seat Rep. Ana Tiburcio now holds, and Republicans Gary Day, Joe Emrick, Ann Flood and Zachary Mako. Republican Milou Mackenzie voted no after voting yes on an earlier version.
In the Senate, which passed it 42-4, Democrats Lisa Boscola and Nick Miller voted yes and Republican Jarrett Coleman voted no.
I send the Valley’s top stories Monday, Wednesday and Friday mornings. Free, and you can leave anytime.
By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy and consent to receive updates.